Banjo’s Top 10 Winter 2016 Anime
by BanjoTheBear
And the winners of Winter 2016 are…
Not too long ago, I had a conversation with one of my uncles about films. We were watching Pixar’s Up at the time, and he said something that caused us to get into a (calm) argument.
“Animated stuff will never make for top-tier experiences.”
It is his belief that films like Schindler’s List and Rain Man will always be better than something like Toy Story or Finding Nemo — simply because the former are “real” while the latter aren’t.
Obviously, I disagreed.
How could I not? While the conversation was geared at computer-generated animation, my mind instantly went to anime. It’s the same principle. Yes, anime about giant, metal balls or high-school kids competing with hover boots may not be the next All About Eve. But anime has the capacity to tell intricate stories. The rationality to explore relatable characters. The ability to simply be downright fun.
I could not change his viewpoint (which I tried to do), but, through our small debate, I grew even more fond of this medium that I have come to adore so much.
So it is that, on this day, we look back on the Winter 2016 anime season to reflect on the best of the best, those that prove anime (and other animated media) can be and are top-tier experiences.
This time around, twenty-two anime showed up to fight for a spot. Ten succeeded, but only one claimed the title of Best Anime of Winter 2016.
Before diving into the list, it is important to know two ideas: what counts and the reasoning behind everything.
First, I am an advocate of an anime counting in the season in which it completed. Meaning, whether it is fantastic or not, something like Assassination Classroom Second Season has no place here despite starting in Winter 2016. On the opposite end, an anime like Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen does have a shot since it concluded in Winter 2016 despite starting the season prior.
Meaning, if you do not see Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen here on my list, that means I either did not see it or it was simply not good enough. (It’s the latter!)
I’m going to repeat this statement one more time: An anime counts if it completed in Winter 2016.
Some of my wonderful readers miss this important detail that I adhere to, so, now having said it twice, I get to call them goofballs should that happen again (here and forever after).
Second, each anime has a personalized review that demonstrates why it deserves to be here in the first place. Simply click on an anime’s name to be linked to its review to read my complete thoughts on it. For every review that I wrote for this season, follow this link to my Winter 2016 Reviews page!
With all of the introductions, formalities, and rules out of the way, it is time to get to my Top 10 Winter 2016 Anime!
Honorable Mentions
The anime listed within this section were watched, completed, and reviewed at a time beyond my original run through of the shows from this specific season. Therefore, they do not have a definitive ranking unlike the others further below and do not technically count towards the overall numbered total. However, to qualify for a spot here, they must also have performed so strongly that they could have potentially made it onto the main list itself had I finished them back then.
Boasting nostalgia aplenty, Koyomimonogatari delivers for the fans of this quirky series a nice little in-between of in-betweens. Each short episode features at least one of the leading ladies encountered thus far and her interactions with Araragi as they set out to take part in or outright solve a tiny, explainable mystery nearby. While it does not present anything too new or too interesting overall, it has enough comedy bits and stylistic choices to make for yet another worthwhile outing in this odd yet rewarding franchise.
Candy creates cavities. And should that candy be Japanese dagashi, it also happens to attract a bubbly, hyper, and passionate girl by the name of Hotaru. Dagashi Kashi is an anime that centers on both dagashi and Hotaru, looking at the history, make, and forms of the sweets while adding in some sexual flair here and there. While the educational segments can be dull, and the majority of the characters are even duller, Hotaru carries the show as far along as she possibly can. Alongside some nice character designs and musical pieces, it’s certainly more appealing than a trip to the dentist’s office.
Hallucinations and spirits run rampant in Musaigen no Phantom World, and it is up to Haruhiko, Mai, Reina, Koito, and Kurumi to quell them. While this slice-of-life anime can have the occasional ecchi moment, its comedy, action, and bittersweet happenings are the norm. The cast is weak — on both an individual and group basis — but the show’s subtle theme on togetherness, the very pretty art and animation, and the good voice-acting performances keep it from falling fully behind. All in all, it’s quite the colorful adventure.
If statues could talk, what would they say? Sekkou Boys lets its audience know that marble wouldn’t just speak; they would sing. Following St. Giorgio, Mars, Hermes, Medici, and their stressed-out manager Miki, the anime focuses on being quirky, silly, and funny. Animation and music (minus the ED, of course) may not be its strong suit, but its varied jokes, fact-based characters, and short length keep this one from being a bust.
7. Akagami no Shirayuki-hime 2nd Season
Akagami no Shirayuki-hime 2nd Season marks the return of Shirayuki, Zen, and the rest of the gang, as well as the second appearance of this series on these lists. For this iteration, Raj and Obi take up the majority of the spotlight. To be fair, it gives their characters a lot of strength, but it also disrupts the focus on Shirayuki and Zen’s story. Regardless, the gorgeous visuals, the theme on home, and the heart-skipping romance make this anime an apple worth biting into.
For the cast of Hai to Gensou no Grimgar, they struggle in a fantastical world filled with monsters, grief, and pain. The anime makes realism its go-to motif: enemies with emotions, soul-crushing events, and grounded interactions. Its unnecessary sexual content gets in the way, but nice characters, interesting music, and beautiful watercolor backgrounds support the show throughout its run. The reality is that its an anime at least worth checking out.
5. Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans
As the people on Mars succumb to troubles on both the social and economic scales, a ragtag group of kids joins forces with Kudelia, a stalwart princess who seeks to correct these wrongs. Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans follows this unlikely pairing across planets and space itself with a couple of strong main and supporting characters, a story-esque artistic direction, and lots of really cool robots. The narrative may have a few hiccups, but its mettle proves to be as tough as iron.
Anime has more than its fair share of girls, but they, unlike the main trio of Oshiete! Galko-chan, do not usually talk about what happens to an in-use tampon submerged in water. Such topics are the usual for Galko, Otako, and Ojou in this short, girly comedy. The relevant sexual material, its theme on “the inside, not the outside, matters most,” and the colorful art are just some of its positives. And of course, making the private girl talk public gives the anime even more intrigue — especially for the males out there. Periods or no, these girls are a cute bunch to watch.
Sometimes, people look back on life and wonder, “Was there more I could have done?” For Satoru of Erased, this question is the one he seeks to answer. The suspenseful narrative, a theme on believing, and his mother Sachiko are some of its strengths. Particular characters are not that meaningful, and certain choices near the ending are controversial. Yet one cannot deny its interesting artistic direction and wonderful music (especially the ED). It’s a thrilling ride that won’t be erased anytime soon.
KonoSuba does not have purposeful themes, deep characters, or even a meaningful message. But that doesn’t stop it from being absolutely hilarious. Kazuma, Aqua, Megumin, and Darkness are a mishmash of ridiculousness. Parody oozes from each encounter the group faces. And its different brands of comedy (which I investigated in my essay KonoSuba and Comedy Through Theory) demonstrate why the show is so gosh darn funny. The world they live in may not be so wonderful, but the anime certainly has received a blessing or two.
1. Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu
More than earning the title of Best Anime of Winter 2016, Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu reaches a level of execution that is almost unheard of. The writing is dramatic and clever. The visuals are a symbolic treat. The characters are complex in their emotions and layered in their connections. The music is beautiful in its composition. And the maturity in its material, the absurd amount of technical proficiency, and the way in which it challenges how one approaches the medium turn it into an unforgettable experience. While just a man’s life story, it ends up being one of the best anime of all time, making its spot at the top of this list a no-brainer.
And that’s it! As always, I want to thank each and every person who supported me throughout my reviews for this season. From the kind words to the insightful comments, from the people who checked out just the summaries to the people who read every single word. I am and always will be eternally grateful for the constant stream of love delivered my way.
Spring 2016 is just over the horizon! :3
The Chuuni Corner 
Good morning Banjo,
This is probably just another elaborate way of the world telling me that I should just watch Shouwa Rengoku, even though the first episode bored me to tears. Winter 2016 has probably been too long ago already for me to remember anything but the very best shows from the season so I had to grab a quick list with what I actually watched during the season. Then again you already seem to disagree with me straight from the get-go by excluding Utawarerumono from the list.
Sure, Utawarerumono had it’s fair share of problems (the story was bland, the character motivations were non-sensical, it was rushed, predictable and had not real ending), but if you compare the slice of life first half of the show to half the other shows on your top 10 (that might be an exagerated amount), I think it definitely deserves a place up there.
Musaigen Phantom World was in my opinion really bad. I’m sorry, I can’t make any more or less of it. I didn’t like Dagashi, but I could see the charm it might have for someone else. Musaigen to me felt like someone had a very interesting idea for a show and the network decided that it would only sell with a dumb amount of unnecessary Ecchi added to it. Seriously, the lack of respect the show has for it’s characters felt bad to me to the point of complete and utter disbelief that anyone could take this show serious. I’d rank it in the same group of shows with Comet Lucifer, Gunslinger Stratos and Seikon no Qwaser, the very bottom of the barrel after everything else.
Besides that there’s not too much to seriously comment on. Didnt watch gundam nor Shouw Rengoku, so I can’t judge either of those, I enjoyed Erased, Grimgar, KonoSuba, Akagami (actually there’s more to comment on, I think Akagami should be higher.), and all the others on your list I can at least say that they were enjoyable and I could say that they’d rank higher on someone else’s list because of taste.
On that note though, can I quickly rant about Fukuyama Jun’s performance in Akagami, which was absolutely magnificent. (He’s prince Raj, though I doubt I’ll have to tell you.) A heartwarming love story with silly yet somewhat realistic characters that actually has a relationship develop instead of the normal “senpai noticed me after 24 episodes, the end.”
I do like that you ranked Grimgar fairly high where some of the youtube reviewers I follow seemed to dislike it a lot more than I did. I really enjoyed the atmosphere the show had, and the art was just amazing in general.
This ended up turning into waaaaay too long of a rant, but that’s what happens when I don’t show my face here for almost a year. I do read through your reviews from time to time, I just haven’t really found the time nor will to comment much lately (too much stuff going on, you know the drill).
Keep up the good work though and I’ll try to pop up some more often here and there!
Have a good day!
Nick/Fesquera
LikeLiked by 1 person